Final Four
| Competitor Name | Times Picked |
| Dream On | 6051 |
| Sweet Emotion | 5293 |
| Walk This Way | 5280 |
| I Don't Want To Miss A Thing | 3483 |
| Back In The Saddle | 2107 |
| Dude (Looks Like a Lady) | 1135 |
| Living On The Edge | 836 |
| Cryin' | 804 |
| Love In An Elevator | 734 |
| Mama Kin | 706 |
| Crazy | 620 |
| What It Takes | 477 |
| Angel | 469 |
| Jaded | 410 |
| Seasons of Wither | 397 |
| Train Kept a Rollin' | 371 |
| Lord Of The Thighs | 357 |
| Eat The Rich | 344 |
| Same Old Song and Dance | 311 |
| Toys In The Attic | 285 |
| Pink | 242 |
| Kings & Queens | 236 |
| F.I.N.E. | 201 |
| Last Child | 164 |
| Nobody's Fault | 154 |
| You See Me Crying | 135 |
| The Other Side | 111 |
| No More No More | 101 |
| Baby Please Don't Go | 100 |
| Falling In Love (Is Hard On The Knees) | 81 |
| Round and Round | 78 |
| Mother Popcorn | 43 |
Championship Match
| Competitor Name | Times Picked |
| Dream On | 4832 |
| Sweet Emotion | 3578 |
| I Don't Want To Miss A Thing | 1943 |
| Walk This Way | 1469 |
| Back In The Saddle | 603 |
| Living On The Edge | 356 |
| Love In An Elevator | 307 |
| Dude (Looks Like a Lady) | 289 |
| Seasons of Wither | 247 |
| What It Takes | 234 |
| Cryin' | 219 |
| Train Kept a Rollin' | 200 |
| Mama Kin | 197 |
| Crazy | 190 |
| Angel | 154 |
| Jaded | 145 |
| Toys In The Attic | 136 |
| Same Old Song and Dance | 127 |
| Pink | 121 |
| Lord Of The Thighs | 102 |
| Eat The Rich | 84 |
| Kings & Queens | 78 |
| Last Child | 73 |
| Nobody's Fault | 63 |
| No More No More | 58 |
| You See Me Crying | 54 |
| F.I.N.E. | 51 |
| The Other Side | 45 |
| Falling In Love (Is Hard On The Knees) | 43 |
| Baby Please Don't Go | 29 |
| Mother Popcorn | 16 |
| Round and Round | 15 |
Champion
| Competitor Name | Times Picked |
| Dream On | 3646 |
| Sweet Emotion | 1111 |
| Walk This Way | 870 |
| I Don't Want To Miss A Thing | 773 |
| Back In The Saddle | 181 |
| Seasons of Wither | 126 |
| Living On The Edge | 125 |
| Train Kept a Rollin' | 123 |
| Dude (Looks Like a Lady) | 117 |
| Love In An Elevator | 117 |
| What It Takes | 94 |
| Mama Kin | 94 |
| Cryin' | 74 |
| Toys In The Attic | 65 |
| Crazy | 64 |
| Angel | 61 |
| Pink | 49 |
| Jaded | 43 |
| Kings & Queens | 36 |
| Nobody's Fault | 34 |
| Lord Of The Thighs | 34 |
| Last Child | 31 |
| Eat The Rich | 29 |
| No More No More | 28 |
| Same Old Song and Dance | 25 |
| F.I.N.E. | 19 |
| The Other Side | 14 |
| Falling In Love (Is Hard On The Knees) | 14 |
| You See Me Crying | 12 |
| Baby Please Don't Go | 11 |
| Mother Popcorn | 5 |
| Round and Round | 4 |
|